Images © Alison M. Jones. · Website content © No Water No Life®, LLC. All rights reserved.
On the Gibe Dams:
An Omo-Turkana Basin Threat
The Omo-Turkana Basin
(Courtesy of International Rivers)
Since 2003, NWNL has visited, documented and researched issues in Ethiopia’s Lower Omo River Basin and its terminus Kenya’s Lake Turkana Basin. We have considered the region’s paleo-history, more recent cultural heritage, agricultural potential, natural flooding patterns, and the future impacts of new Gibe Dams and associated foreign-owned plantation schemes.
Our on-the-ground advisor-guide for our five Omo and Turkana Expeditions was Halewijn Scheuerman. (See our in-depth INTERVIEW with HALEWIJN for his unique perspective as an Omo-Turkana explorer/anthropologist.) Our NGO partner in raising awareness of the impacts of Ethiopia’s new hydro-dams on the Gibe River has been International Rivers. Their 2014 video “A Cascade of Development,” using many NWNL images, is described below. This film is also described in further detail on our Omo Videos page, along with ”The Vanishing Lake,” a film exploring issues facing Lake Turkana as a result of the Gibe Dams.
Updated information on impacts of the Gibe Dams, new irrigation and infrastructure installations will be added to this page.
A Cascade of Development
This International Rivers video with NWNL imagery outlines how Ethiopia’s new Gibe Dams could cause a 70% water-level reduction within 3 years. Their water retention would drastically impact Ethiopia’s Omo River; Kenya’s Lake Turkana; and half a million residents in the Rift Valley’s “Cradle of Humankind.“
These hydro-dams – and new commercial agricultural schemes depending on their water sources – threaten the livelihoods of local indigenous tribes and their ecosystems. The Gibe Dams will also imperil the Omo-Turkana Basin’s migrating birds, fish and crocodile populations, and scant amount of remaining wildlife.
Traditional Omo Culture: Three generations of women overlooking Lower Omo River
The film pleads that water flows be managed so as to maintain the sustainability of the Omo River, Lake Turkana, and today’s indigenous tribal communities who represent 6000 years of self-sustaining flood-recession farmers and fishermen. For more information on the Omo River, read the Gibe Dam PDF Reports (in the sidebar at left), gathered by NWNL.
Floods rising 60 feet after monsoonal rains have traditionally supplied nutrient-rich silt and irrigation for crops of the Mursi, Suri, Karo, Hamar, Nyangatom, Dassanech and other local, indigenous cultures. Ian Stevenson (former head of African Parks’ project in Omo National Park) described these tribes to NWNL as “highly developed in their society and also incredibly intelligent.” But hydro-dams that stop annual flooding will end the enriching silt deposition and flood-recession agriculture in the Lower Omo Valley. This will dramatically reduce harvests and impair their self-sustaining livelihoods.
Omo farming: Karo villager standing amidst sorghum
The pros and cons of dam-building in the Omo Valley – as in any watershed – should include weighing cultural and environmental impacts. Sadly, Ethiopia minimized such preliminary processes as it focused on the profits of selling hydro-electricity to neighboring countries.
International Rivers, frequently using NWNL images, explained the impacts of the proposed dams to the dams’ original funders (World Bank, USAID, European Investment Bank and African Development Bank). Citing a lack of due process required by Ethiopia’s own Constitution, these funders withdrew their money in 2010.
Aerial view of third Gibe River dam under construction in the Upper Omo River Basin
However, Ethiopia accepted China’s immediate offer to help fund and construct these dams. Since, Ethiopia has encouraged foreign agricultural investors to buy the rich, riparian Omo Valley lands, especially as these new dams would offer year-round irrigation. Now, the Omo’s indigenous communities, having lived and farmed here for 6,000 years, are being relocated.
Explaining Today’s Africa to Westerners
NWNL: You were born in Holland, grew up in Spain, and studied in France before you came to Africa. How do all those perspectives influence your thinking today?
Halewijn Scheuerman: For a moment I would like to be the advocate of the devil [and speak as an African to a Westerner]. In Europe, you were able to make iron. You completely shaped your landscape. Now water has disappeared, more or less. Then you went over the big Atlantic and you did exactly the same, harnessing everything. Now you feel guilty. You come to this continent and tell us we cannot follow the same path. That means we have to stay poor. We cannot be privileged like you taking airplanes and all this.
Simple life: A Dassenech tribal elder on Ethiopia’s Omo River
Things you find normal in the Western world and America – you would like Africa not to do it. That’s the big problem, because African leaders are going to [want what you have]. You come in a paternalistic way often, advising and so on and so on – with good intentions, I know. Both sides are very well intended – the Westerners and Africans – but there are things we cannot stop, even when you are well intentioned. It doesn’t work, even in terms of conservation.
NWNL: What’s your opinion of the proposed cascade of five hydro-dams on the Gibe River?
Halewijn Scheuerman: At the end, Africa’s political leaders are the ones who decide. It’s not anymore an international body or colonial power, or so on and so on. I have heard often money is the solution, money. Money is not a solution. It’s not about windowpanes. It’s not about the cleanness of the school classrooms. It’s not about how smart the houses look.
Now, the Omo is healthy. It’s very healthy. The floods are at the moment very dramatic. Everybody has every reason to be happy. Those areas that are flooding are going to be fields for months and months. As those flooded areas recede, they’re going to plant.
Flooding in the Omo River Delta
The Karo have a lake called Lake Diba, and it fills up and empties depending on the floods of the Omo. It’s been dry for a long time, and now it is back to its full size, full of fish – a lot of Nile perch, and so on. As it recedes, crocodiles will go back to the main Omo and the Karo will start planting. The Karo say, “This is our bank account.”
[Transcription edited for clarity by Alison M. Jones, NWNL Director. Our Interview Guidelines describe the NWNL protocol for editing raw transcripts.]
NWNL Response To Halewijn – 2014
Halewijn Scheuerman and friends in the village of Tourmi, Omo River Valley, Ethiopia
Halewijn Scheuerman seems to have been right. Ethiopia’s political leaders are the ones who are deciding the future of the Omo Valley. But when the Karo and other Omo communities lose their gift of Omo River floods, the Turkana and other Kenyans will lose the world’s largest desert lake and its fisheries (their main source of protein). These “bank accounts” will be gone for good.
As well, we all will have lost some of the warp and woof of our 6,000-year-old global tapestry. Halewijn rightfully noted the West is just as guilty as Africa of trampling over traditional riparian rights in our economic march forward. We can better assess risks and tread more carefully. The world’s security lies in whether or not we can establish well-considered and balanced approaches to the universal issue of riparian rights.
Water for All Communities:
Developed and Non-Developed
[Posted by NWNL on Aug. 22, 2014;
Revised by NWNL on August 31, 2017]
All images © Alison M. Jones. All rights reserved.